Garnishments and Frozen Bank Accounts

If a person borrows money and is late in repaying it, the lender may choose to sue to collect the debt. A lender starts a suit by filing a “summons and complaint” in state court. The summons and complaint is “served” (delivered to) the borrower. The method of service should be reflected on the “return of service” noted in the court’s file.

A suit that has been properly served requires that the defendant/borrower file an “answer” within 30 days of having been served with the suit. The answer should state a cognizable reason why the borrower is not legally obligated to pay as alleged by the creditor.

If the borrower files his answer on time, a hearing will be assigned. If he wins the argument at the hearing, a judgment will be entered in his favor. Otherwise, if the borrower fails to answer, or if an answer is inadequate to dispute the default, then the creditor will win. The creditor may then use the judgment as the basis for a “garnishment” or “levy” to collect the money owed to it.

A “garnishment” is a proceeding where the creditor requires the borrower’s employer to pay a percentage of the debtor’s wages into the court until the judgment is satisfied. A garnishment is served on the employer, not on the employee. Thus, it is not necessary for the creditor to “serve” (notify) the borrower of the garnishment, and it may hit the borrower unexpectedly.

Alternatively, a garnishment can also take the form of a “levy”. Here, the creditor may cause the debtor’s bank account to be frozen, and have the bank pay the monies over after a brief waiting period. Again, the borrower does not need to be directly notified, and is often surprised to find that his funds have been frozen. A levy may attach to a joint account even if the other owner(s) of the account have nothing to do with the debt owed to the creditor.

Bankruptcy is commonly used as a defensive action to stop lawsuits, garnishments, and levies. If bankruptcy is filed before a judgment is entered, the bankruptcy will prevent the suit from going forward. If a judgment has been already entered, then at state law, the debt becomes “secured” by a “judicial lien”. In bankruptcy court, a judicial lien may be “avoided” if the lien “impairs exemptions” to which the Debtor would otherwise be entitled. A judgement usually “impairs exemptions” where the Debtor does not own significant equity in property. (This subject is beyond the scope of this article, and would have to be discussed specifically with the lawyer).

If monies have already been taken under a garnishment or levy, it may still be possible to get the money back. Basically, the monies taken must be capable of being “exempted” in the individual case. Further, the amount must still be in the possession of the employer, bank, or court, or alternatively, if the monies have been remitted to the creditor, they must have been garnished within 90 days of the bankruptcy filing, and must exceed $600.00 in amount. These matters are frequently (but not always) resolved in favor of the Debtor. Resolution depends on the facts of the individual case.

Please contact one of our lawyers at 770-683-3303 to discuss how this applies in your particular situation. 

WHAT IS THE “TRUSTEE”?

In the broadest sense, the bankruptcy “Trustee” refers to the Office of the United States Trustee, which is part of the United States Department of Justice. The Trustee comes from the executive branch of the government, which is different from the bankruptcy judge, who is part of the judicial branch of government.

The mission of the Trustee is to promote integrity and efficiency in bankruptcy cases for the benefit of both debtors and creditors. The Trustee’s office oversees the administration of cases, and is a “watchdog” to prevent fraud and abuse.

As a practical matter, the “Trustee” in a particular case is a lawyer who “administers” the bankruptcy estate. In a Chapter 13 reorganization, the Trustee conducts the first court hearing (the “Meeting of Creditors”), and makes recommendations to the bankruptcy judge with regard to the approval (“confirmation”) or rejection (“dismissal”) of Chapter 13 plans. After the plan is accepted, the Trustee monitors the debtor’s performance under the approved plan.

The Chapter 13 Trustee also takes in “plan payments” from debtors each month, and then pays those monies out to creditors. In the Northern District of Georgia, the Chapter 13 Trustee has an office in Atlanta with several lawyers and support staff. The Chapter 13 Trustee takes in millions and millions of dollars from debtors, and then disburses those monies to creditors each month.

In Chapter 7, the “Trustee” plays a different role. In Chapter 7, a local “case Trustee” is assigned to conduct the first court hearing (“Meeting of Creditors”) and to “administer” the estate. A Chapter 7 case is a “liquidation” case. The general purpose of the Trustee is to liquidate (sell) “assets of the estate”. These consist of the debtor’s property as of the date of filing to the extent that the property is worth more than what the debtor is allowed to “exempt” (keep for himself). The Chapter 7 estate does not include the debtor’s wages after the case is filed, though it may include assets inherited within six months of filing, or the recovery of monies from law suits.

As a practical matter, the vast majority of Chapter 7 cases are “no asset” cases. This means that there are no assets for the Trustee to sell, and usually the debts that are owed to a debtor’s creditors are “discharged” without any payment whatsoever. The reason is that “exemptions” permitted to debtors are fairly generous, so that people who don’t own very much property free of liens are usually permitted to keep that property. (If property has a lien on it, it belongs to the creditor to the extent of the lien, and the Trustee has no interest apart from the “equity” in it.)

As explained elsewhere, “exemptions” are allowances permitted under the law in different dollar amounts in different categories of property. One of the jobs of the debtor’s lawyer is to evaluate the property that you own and determine what you can protect (“exempt”). If you are at risk of losing something that you don’t want to lose, sometimes Chapter 13 is the superior choice, or sometimes you may have non-bankruptcy options. The key to making safe decisions is to clearly disclose what property you own to your lawyer in the early stages of consultation.

Please call Newnan Bankruptcy at 770-683-3303 to discuss your particular situation with our lawyers. 

Bankruptcies and Vehicle Repossession: Q & A

Q: I was a little behind on my car payments, and my car was repossessed. Can filing a bankruptcy help me get it back?

A: Yes. Chapter 13’s are often used to cure defaults on car notes. Having the car repossessed does not in and of itself make you lose all of your rights in the car. So long as you have any remaining rights, you can usually use a Chapter 13 to force the lender to give it back and let you pay for it through your Chapter 13 plan. Read more “Bankruptcies and Vehicle Repossession: Q & A”

Bankruptcies and Foreclosure: Q & A

Q: I’m behind on the house payments. My bank stopped accepting payments, and I received a letter saying that my mortgage has been referred to a lawyer for foreclosure. What does that mean? Will filing a bankruptcy help this situation?

A: “Foreclosure” is the process by which the lender on real estate takes title back from the borrower because of a default, usually by missing payments. There is no minimum number of missed payments that will trigger this action. If payments are not made according to the schedule set out in the note, the bank has the discretion to foreclose.

Read more “Bankruptcies and Foreclosure: Q & A”

What’s the difference between Chapter 7 and Chapter 13?

Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 are different tools that are used to handle different financial problems. Chapter 13 is a debt consolidation plan used to repay debt in full or in part over a period of years. Chapter 7 is a fresh start or liquidation case that is usually finished after only a few months.

In Chapter 13, you can force secured creditors like mortgage lenders or car lenders to allow you to cure defaults over time, whether they agree or not. In Chapter 7, unsecured debts are discharged without payment, and you indicate your preference (intent) as to whether or not you want to “reaffirm” and keep paying your secured creditors. Alternatively, you may surrender the collateral and discharge the debt.

Read more “What’s the difference between Chapter 7 and Chapter 13?”